4 Year Old Asked to Take Off Leg Braces for Security at PHL
February 19th, 2010In one of the strangest stories this week, a 4 year old boy was asked by the TSA in Philadelphia to remove his leg braces and put them through an x-ray machine. The boy needed the braces to walk and he was made to go through the machine without the aide of his mother.
Here is the twist. The boy’s Dad is a Police Detective form Camden, New Jersey.
What is the problem with this story? If you recall in the interview with Bob Crandall on an earlier post, he says that intelligence is what is needed to protect people. Bob Schneier who is a security expert coins the TSA efforts as Security Theater.
I used to call on Garber Travel in Boston. The old man, Bernie Garber was a man with sayings. The first one you learned form him was that “Companies do not do business with companies, people do business with people.” So, to borrow from Bernie, “Objects don’t try to kill people, people try to kill people.”
The current security system being operated is a waste of money and ineffective. The unfortunate process that works is profiling. For every old lady, 4 year old little, or middle-aged Father of 2 they pull from the line, the real people they need to speak to are probably getting throw their silly gauntlet.
I always tell the story of my experience after 9/11. I was in Hungary for my cousins wedding. In Budapest, the Hungarians pulled out the old Communist playbook for handling the crowds. The sterilized the airport and had multiple passport checks in place. They were not so much concerned about my bags, as they were about me.
Here, the whole system is set up to find objects instead of people. It’s completely backwards.
The TSA apologized for what they made the family do. Let’s face it. The system is totally broken and an alternative needs to be put into place. It is killing our airline industry and putting a crimp in economic development. Fewer people are inclined to travel knowing the hassle with TSA at the airport.
We should all be apologizing to the family in Philadelphia because our irrational fears and realize that we should be looking for people, not things.

modernizing the home with a new kitchen to a 2 car garage with opener. It is a home that has a small moment in history as the last place that Admiral Horthy the leader of Hungary during the interwar period stayed before his exile to Portugal.

